Sallie Bingham

  • Events
  • Blog
    • Doris Duke
    • Best of 2024
    • My Favorites
    • Full Archives
    • Writing
    • Women
    • Philanthropy
    • My Family
    • Politics
    • Kentucky
    • New Mexico
    • Travel
    • Art
    • Theater
    • Religion
  • Books & Plays
    • Doris Duke
    • Fiction
    • Nonfiction
    • Plays
    • Poetry
    • Anthologies
  • Writing
    • Short Stories
    • Poems
    • Plays
    • Translations
  • Resources
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Print
    • Biography
  • About
    • Contact
 
You are here: Home / New Mexico / Hagiography: The Copied Pot, The Repeated Story

Hagiography: The Copied Pot, The Repeated Story

August 26th, 2014 by Sallie Bingham in New Mexico, Art Leave a Comment

Santa Fe Indian Market

Santa Fe Indian Market

I spent several hours this past weekend walking through the displays at Santa Fe’s annual Indian Market, said to be the largest gathering of Native artists and craftspeople in the world, and now more than ninety years old.

This edited show always shows the same kind of beautiful wares, made in the pueblos of New Mexico and on the Navajo reservation: clay pots, formed of local clay, fired in outdoor ovens and painted meticulously by hand with the designs that have come down for generations; blankets and rugs, also duplicating age-old patterns and colors, and kachinas and other sculptures copying models that allow for little variation or invention.

These things are beautiful, their beauty sometimes astounding, and it is what the buyers are looking for: an imitation of the past, to take home to Texas or California, to display on a shelf and be rather quickly forgotten.

Indian Market is hagiography in visual form; the copying and idealization for the past—a past that was tragic, but that bred people of enormous resilience, multiplying through the generations that followed the U.S. genocide, surviving because of their faith in always moving forward.

In choosing invention, I chose my own view, my own voice, as I chose the woven forms of the marble statue I bought at Indian Market from a young Navajo sculptor.

As a Navajo leader said when reminded that yesterday was the 150th anniversary of The Long Walk, he and his people do not think or speak of that disaster, and they do no visit the palliative monument at Fort Sumpter.

But they must make a living. For generations, they have managed to survive by making highly-skilled copies of the beautiful, but also utilitarian, objects their ancestors perfected—pots to hold water, blankets to keep out the cold. These modern reproductions are beautiful, but they have no utility.

A fierce debate arose here recently between the Natives and their white supporters who champion the old way—the way of hagiography—and younger artists who want to develop original designs. The debate led to the splitting of the market into two parts; the traditionalists claimed, as always, the Plaza at the center of town, the innovators settled into the new city park, the Railyard.

Santa Fe Indian Market

Santa Fe Indian Market

This debate will probably never be resolved, at least as long as buyers prefer to spend their money on copies. For, no matter how skilled, how beautiful, these traditional pots and rugs are, they allow no room for the maker’s initiative, for the untrammeled use of her/his vision, for art that reaches into the future, rather than into the past.

The traps of hagiography are all about us. In my new book, The Blue Box: Three Lives in Letters, just published by Sarabande Books, I faced the danger of idealizing the women in my mother’s family, whose letters form the basis of my work: of imitating the sweetness of my great-grandmother’s memories, a Sallie who never saw anything disagreeable, even during the Civil War in Richmond, Virginia, or copying my grandmother’s use of humor to paste over, in the acceptable way, the miseries of her life, or my mother’s attempt, successful as it turned out, to disguise and then justify dishonorable behavior. All of them were copying a familiar stereotype, not a Navajo rug but the Angel in the House, that plaster nineteenth century icon whose self-righteousness sometimes allowed for very questionable motives and acts.

Writing about one’s family’s past always raises the issue of hagiography: whether to coat these past lives with maple syrup, to make these renditions as palatable to today’s readers as they would have been to the women who wrote the letters. No room, then, for sharp intuition, for cutting through the veils thrown over unpleasant events and people, to copy a familiar model—the biographies of the saints—rather than sailing off into unknown and often dangerous territory.

In choosing invention, I chose my own view, my own voice, as I chose the woven forms of the marble statue I bought at Indian Market from a young Navajo sculptor. It won a blue ribbon, but that did not endear it to the shoppers hurrying past to study one more pueblo pot. But for me, the twists and turns of the white marble are the same twists and turns that animate my imagination and my writing. For the artist, as for the writer, there is in the end no turning back.

Photos from SWAIA, and Cholula Red.

Share
Tweet
Share
Buffer
0 Shares

In New Mexico, Art New Mexico Santa Fe Indian Market Navajo The Long Walk Fort Sumpter

A long and fruitful career as a writer began in 1960 with the publication of Sallie Bingham's novel, After Such Knowledge. This was followed by 15 collections of short stories in addition to novels, memoirs and plays, as well as the 2020 biography The Silver Swan: In Search of Doris Duke.

Her latest book, Taken by the Shawnee, is a work of historical fiction published by Turtle Point Press in June of 2024. Her previous memoir, Little Brother, was published by Sarabande Books in 2022. Her short story, "What I Learned From Fat Annie" won the Thomas Wolfe Fiction Prize in 2023 and the story "How Daddy Lost His Ear," from her forthcoming short story collection How Daddy Lost His Ear and Other Stories (September 23, 2025), received second prize in the 2023 Sean O’Faolain Short Story Competition.

She is an active and involved feminist, working for women’s empowerment, who founded the Kentucky Foundation for Women, which gives grants to Kentucky artists and writers who are feminists, The Sallie Bingham Center for Women's History and Culture at Duke University, and the Women’s Project and Productions in New York City. She lives in Santa Fe, New Mexico.

Sallie's complete biography is available here.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

You might also like

  • When We Fight We Win
    When We Fight We Win
    The presence, the faces, and the words of the Navajo were themselves living images, engraving on my mind the urgency of a cause I've known about for years but never felt personally....
  • Photo of Las Trampas Church figurine
    The Meaning of Work
    Recently I toured the Las Trampas Church where the elaborate interior, with altar screen, bultos, and other religious paintings was being skillfully restored by local craftsmen....
  • Photo of Dorothy Brett in New Mexico
    Maybe Brett
    Blessed as I always am in my work, I've discovered a possible new topic for a biography in the life of the British/American painter, Dorothy Brett....
  • Photo of a bear on my patio
    My Bear Is Back
    I know she/they are back because my tube bird feeders are lying on the ground, seeds scattered and gone....
 

Subscribe

 

Latest Comments

  • Martha White on The Fruits of the Past Five Years: “Eudora Welty’s One Writer’s Beginnings: “And suddenly a light is thrown back, as when your train makes a curve, showing…” July 6th, 11:14 am
  • Nenita on The Fruits of the Past Five Years: “I like your writings, I can relate to you. If I had been persevering and seriously aware of my interests…” July 6th, 11:13 am
  • Sallie Bingham on Whose Eyes: “Thank you, James – you are correct!” June 29th, 11:19 am
  • Martha White on Feeding the Fish: “Blinkying Report:: Our neighborhood rabbits have been observed leaping into the air three or four feet off the ground. It…” June 29th, 8:10 am
  • Martha White on Whose Eyes: “Subtle. The “b” stays silent—subtle, even.” June 24th, 12:59 pm

Watch Sallie

Taken By The Shawnee

Taken By The Shawnee

July 6th, 2025
Sallie Bingham introduces and reads from her latest work, Taken by the Shawnee.
Visiting Linda Stein

Visiting Linda Stein

March 3rd, 2025
Back on October 28th, 2008, I visited artist Linda Stein's studio in New York City and tried on a few of her handmade suits of armor.

Listen To Sallie

Rebecca Reynolds & Salie Bingham at SOMOS

Rebecca Reynolds & Salie Bingham at SOMOS

November 8th, 2024
This event was recorded November 1, 2024 in Taos, NM at SOMOS Salon & Bookshop by KCEI Radio, Red River/Taos and broadcast on November 8, 2024.
Taken by the Shawnee Reading

Taken by the Shawnee Reading

September 1st, 2024
This reading took place at The Church of the Holy Faith in Santa Fe, New Mexico in August of 2024.

Upcoming Events

Jul 25
July 25th - July 27th

The 9th Annual Taos Writers Conference

SOMOS Salon & Bookshop
Taos MO
Sep 23
All day

How Daddy Lost His Ear – Garcia Street Books

Garcia Street Books
Santa Fe NM
Sep 30
3:00 pm - 4:30 pm MDT

How Daddy Lost His Ear – The Church of the Holy Faith

The Church of the Holy Faith
Santa Fe NM
View all of Sallie's events

Latest Tweets

salliebingham avatar Sallie Bingham @salliebingham ·
10 Jul 1943388047287963824

Recently, I was reflecting with my good friend John on the fruits of the past five years. I’m so very grateful for all my readers who keep me and my books alive! https://buff.ly/NgnRjO3 #DorisDuke #TheSilverSwan #Treason #LittleBrother #TakenByTheShawnee #HowDaddyLostHisEar

Image for the Tweet beginning: Recently, I was reflecting with Twitter feed image.
salliebingham avatar Sallie Bingham @salliebingham ·
9 Jul 1942957873966792785

It's important not to be ploughed under by the chaos and intemperance in #WashingtonDC. We don't live in that swamp, and we don't need to allow our hopes and dreams to be drowned out by the noise. "Reasons to Hope": https://buff.ly/Z8lH33D

Image for the Tweet beginning: It's important not to be Twitter feed image.
Load More

Recent Press

Sallie Bingham's latest is a captivating account of ancestor's ordeal
Pasatiempo, The Santa Fe New Mexican

“I felt she was with me” during the process of writing the book, Bingham says. “I felt I wasn’t writing anything that would have seemed to her false or unreal.”

Copyright © 2025 Sallie Bingham. All Rights Reserved.

Press Materials   —   Contact Sallie

Privacy Policy

Menu
  • Events
  • Blog
    • Doris Duke
    • Best of 2024
    • My Favorites
    • Full Archives
    • Writing
    • Women
    • Philanthropy
    • My Family
    • Politics
    • Kentucky
    • New Mexico
    • Travel
    • Art
    • Theater
    • Religion
  • Books & Plays
    • Doris Duke
    • Fiction
    • Nonfiction
    • Plays
    • Poetry
    • Anthologies
  • Writing
    • Short Stories
    • Poems
    • Plays
    • Translations
  • Resources
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Print
    • Biography
  • About
    • Contact